Defense for Federal Government Investigations
I Have Been Served with a Subpoena — What Now?
The best first step is the simplest: do not contact the prosecutor — contact counsel. Steven Brill handles federal and SEC subpoenas.
- Federal & state trial defense
- Founding partner Steven Brill · since 2001
- Free & confidential · 24/7
If you have been served with a subpoena, the simplest answer is the best one: contact an attorney — do not contact the prosecutor who issued it. A subpoena carries enormous obligations and significant consequences; ignoring it can bring criminal or civil punishment, while calling the author can turn a witness into a "person of interest" or a target. You also have rights, including the Fifth Amendment right to remain silent and the right to move to quash the subpoena.
The service of a subpoena is one of the most obvious ways federal, state, or local government offices use their power — and receiving one can be unpleasant and downright scary. A subpoena is an official document, sometimes signed by a judge, attorney, or grand jury foreman, seeking the production of documents and/or your appearance at an official proceeding. It may come from the U.S. Attorney’s Office, the Securities and Exchange Commission, the New York State Attorney General, or a District Attorney’s Office. No matter who served it, the question is the same: what do I do now?
Do not contact the prosecutor
You may feel an urge to call the author of the subpoena to talk and ask questions. Suppress that urge. It is a very risky endeavor to make statements to someone conducting an investigation who may consider you a “person of interest” or a “target.” Even if you are only a “subject,” you do not want to say anything that changes your status for the worse. Let your lawyer handle all contact.
Your obligations — and the consequences of ignoring them
A subpoena carries real legal weight. If it is not complied with, criminal or civil punishment can result. At the same time, you are not without protection: you should not simply hand over everything, nor should you ignore it. The right course is to have counsel assess what is actually required and how to respond.
Know your rights
- The right to remain silent. If you are a target — for example of the SEC or the U.S. Attorney’s Office — the Fifth Amendment protects you, because statements made in response to a subpoena can be used against you.
- The right to move to quash. A court can reject a subpoena that gives unreasonable time to comply or demands privileged or protected material.
How Sullivan & Brill helps
We have represented many clients who have been served with subpoenas — including federal grand jury and SEC subpoenas. We assess your status, advise precisely what to produce, move to quash where appropriate, and appear with you at any testimony. If you or someone you know has been served, contact us immediately.
Representation: A client retained Steven Brill after receiving an SEC subpoena commanding production of documents and personal appearance at the SEC’s offices. Sullivan & Brill advised on the proper documents to produce and accompanied the client at every stage of live testimony. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Frequently asked questions
Can I just call the prosecutor to explain?
No. Contacting the person who issued the subpoena is risky — anything you say can be used to move you from witness to subject or target. Let your attorney handle all communication.
What happens if I ignore a subpoena?
Ignoring a subpoena can bring criminal or civil punishment, including contempt. The answer is not to ignore it and not to over-comply, but to have counsel respond properly.
Can a subpoena be challenged?
Yes. We can move to quash a subpoena that does not give reasonable time to comply or that demands privileged or otherwise protected material.
Does a subpoena mean I am a target?
Not necessarily — you could be a witness, a subject, or a target. Determining your status, and protecting it, is one of the first things we do.
Free & confidential · Available 24/7
Charged with a crime in New York? Talk to Steven Brill today.
The decisions you make early can shape the entire case. Get a free, confidential assessment of your charges and your options — no pressure, no obligation.