Car Accident Lawyers in New York

Uninsured & Underinsured Motorist Claims in New York

When the at-fault driver has no insurance or not enough, your own UM/SUM coverage steps in. We handle these claims and the arbitrations that decide them.

  • No fee unless we win
  • 30+ years · $21M and $18.5M verdicts
  • Free & confidential · 24/7

In New York, uninsured motorist (UM) coverage pays when the at-fault driver has no insurance or flees; supplementary underinsured motorist (SUM) coverage pays when their policy is too small to cover your damages. Both are claims under your own policy and often resolve through arbitration.

You did everything right and still got hurt by a driver who carried the state minimum — or nothing at all. In New York, the minimum liability policy is small, and serious injuries blow past it fast. The good news is that the coverage on your own car, and sometimes a relative’s, was built for this moment.

Two coverages do the work, and people mix them up constantly. Knowing which one applies, and how much you have, often decides whether you’re fully compensated.

UM vs. SUM: the difference that matters

Uninsured motorist (UM) coverage applies when the at-fault driver has no insurance at all, or is a hit-and-run driver who’s never identified. Every New York auto policy is required to include it.

Supplementary underinsured motorist (SUM) coverage applies when the at-fault driver had insurance, but not enough to cover your damages. SUM pays the gap between the other driver’s liability limit and your SUM limit. If a driver with a $25,000 policy causes $200,000 in damages and you carry $100,000 in SUM, that difference is where your recovery lives.

Here’s what trips people up: SUM is not automatic and its limits vary. Many New Yorkers carry far less SUM than they think, or none beyond the default. We read your declarations page carefully, and we check every policy in the household, because coverage can sometimes be found on more than one vehicle.

How these claims actually work

A UM or SUM claim is a claim against your own insurer, which creates an odd dynamic — the company you pay premiums to is now the adversary valuing your injury. The process usually includes:

  • Prompt written notice to your carrier (deadlines are strict)
  • Exhausting the at-fault driver’s liability policy first, in SUM cases
  • Getting your carrier’s consent to settle before you accept the other driver’s limits
  • Proving your injury meets the §5102(d) serious-injury threshold

Most UM/SUM disputes are resolved in arbitration rather than a courtroom. That’s a hearing with its own rules and rhythm, and how you present medical proof and lost earnings there drives the award.

Don’t hand the insurer an easy out

Two mistakes end otherwise strong claims: settling with the at-fault driver without your carrier’s consent, and missing the notice deadline. Both can void your SUM rights. Talk to a lawyer before you sign anything with the other side’s insurer.

We’ve recovered $4M in a car accident case and a $713,000 Westchester jury verdict after a $12,500 offer. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

If the driver fled the scene, your claim may run through MVAIC and hit-and-run coverage instead. For the full auto picture, see our New York car accident overview, then contact us for a free review of your coverage.

Uninsured and underinsured motorist questions New Yorkers ask

What’s the difference between UM and SUM coverage?

UM pays when the at-fault driver has no insurance or can’t be identified. SUM pays when that driver had insurance but too little to cover your damages, filling the gap up to your own SUM limit.

Can I take the other driver’s settlement and then claim SUM?

Only if you get your own insurer’s written consent to settle first. Accepting the at-fault driver’s limits without consent can wipe out your SUM claim, so check with a lawyer before signing.

Do these claims go to court?

Most UM and SUM claims are decided in arbitration, not a jury trial. The rules differ, and how you present medical and wage evidence at the hearing directly affects the award.

How do I know how much SUM coverage I have?

It’s on your policy’s declarations page, and many people carry less than they assume. We review your policy and every other policy in your household to find all available coverage.

Free consultation · No fee unless we win

Injured in New York? Talk to our team today.

We will review your case for free and explain your options — no pressure, no obligation.

Call 212-566-1000 Start My Free Case Review